Comments

Ask a Pro
Q. What are Some Cheap Ways to Soundproof My Basement Theater?
April 18, 2008 | by John Baumeister
Electronic architect John Baumeister lays out five cost effective methods to achieve sound isolation.
View this entire articleView this entire article
Back to top
7 Comments (displaying chronologically) Post a comment
Posted by Bill  on  04/18  at  06:38 PM

While this response is long on descrition of noise types it is very short on actual solutions.  Specific measures of real world solutions would be more helpful.

Posted by Peter Wiebe  on  04/20  at  08:36 AM

This Q&A;should have been edited prior to being posted. The author’s writing style is challenging to follow to the point of being confusing, and also lacks clarity and focus.  One shouldn’t write “Again,...” if it’s the first time you introduce a concept or solution.  Sentences must contain an object; “As well, reduce the amount.” (the amount of what?).  When discussing well established acoustic phenomena, surely an audio professional can describe how acoustic insulation prevents sound transmission more accurately and clearly than; “Insulation in the wall or ceiling cavities will increase your isolation by removing some of the sound.”  To say that absorption is ineffective at lower frequencies is misleading without explaining why.  All of these things only hurt the credibility of this author.

Posted by Wallo  on  04/20  at  11:13 AM

Another useless article from Electronic House, reminds me of the one on cables.  No specifics, could have been more detailed, more scientific.

Posted by Chuck McKenney  on  04/20  at  11:44 AM

It’s not a “formal” article. Ask a Pro is a new feature of EH where dealers/installers take time to respond to reader questions. The goal isn’t to have the Pro write 1000 words on cheap soundproofing methods. But since the topic has drawn some interest, we’ll have an in-depth article in the near future. Thanks.

Posted by igor  on  04/21  at  09:12 AM

Peter, lighten up. Go read a dictionary.

Posted by wtf  on  04/21  at  12:45 PM

What a bunch of moronic trolls this site attracts.

Short on actual solutions? The author lists 5 sources of noise and offers a way to cut down each of them. How are they not actual solutions? Do you need a brand name of drywall in order to be happy?

This Wiebe clown is just a frustrated wannabe. Like Igor says, go read a dictionary or something. And Wallo’s response is 100% content free. Remember “Wallo” starts with Waaa, so go cry somewhere else, ya tool.

I thought it was a nice quick overview of the steps a home-owner could take. I wasn’t expecting a thesis on sound reduction from short 1 page article.

My follow up question would be, is there anything a renter could do? i.e, any non-permanent solutions to help isolate a room.

Posted by Pat  on  04/22  at  10:37 AM

I just finished my basement theater using QuietRock sheetrock.  It was much less expensive and much less complicated than “decoupling” the installation.  And it got me the great sound proofing.

Page 1 of 1 pages


Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.